- Effects models- how the media affects the audience, further divided into 'Passive' and 'Active'.
- Uses and gratifications- what the audience actually does with the media and what they get from it.
- Reception theory- Obviously, the audiences response- what they do to the media. It is active.
Passive audience theories:
•Mass media/mass communications make
people powerless to resist messages the media carries•Consumers are ‘drugged’, ‘addicted’ or ‘hypnotised’
•Effects theories taken up with protection of young, link between violence and the media.
Examples: Nazi propaganda in Hitler's Germany, Bobo doll experiment (1963).
Criticisms:
•The problems with violence are often
social/psychological- not to do with the media.
•The media can often be positive rather
than harmful.
•Criticism of the media using the effects
model is often politically motivated.
•There is no real grounding of research
and theory for this model.
Two Step Flow Model:
![]() |
| 1 2 |
My personal step flow model:
The Cultural Effects Model:
- Marxist.
- Suggests that the media content contains strong ideological messages that reflect the values of those who control, own and produce the media.
- Media content gradually gains ideological values which are transmitted over a long period of time.
- Eventually, most people come to accept it.
The Hypodermic Syringe Model:
- Audience accept anything they are presented with immediately.
- The model is rooted in 1930s behaviorism.
- It is largely considered obsolete today.
Uses and Gratifications:
- Based on Maslow's 'Hierarchy of Needs'
Dennis McQuail (1987):
•Information:
finding out about the world; seeking advice; satisfying curiosity; education;
gaining security though knowledge.
•Personal
Identity: reinforcement of personal values; models of behaviour;
identifying
with valued other; gaining insight into oneself.
•Integration and Social
Interaction: gaining insight into circumstances of others; identifying
with others; basis for conversation with others; substitute for real life
companionship;
helping to carry out social roles; enabling connection with
family friends and society.
•Entertainment: escapism; diversion;
relaxation; cultural or aesthetic enjoyment; filling
time; emotional release;
sexual arousal.
James Lull (1990):
Structural
•Environmental:
background noise; companionship; entertainment
•Regulative:
keeping
time; part of pattern of daily life
Relational
•Communication
Facilitation:
experience illustration; common ground;
conversation starter; anxiety reduction; agenda for talk; value
clarification
•Affiliation/Avoidance: physical/verbal
contact/neglect; family solidarity; family
relaxant/conflict reducer; relationship maintenance
•Social
Learning: decision making; behaviour
modelling; problem solving; value
transmission; legitimization; information
dissemination; education
•Competence/Dominance: role
enactment; role reinforcement; substitute role portrayal;
intellectual
validation; authority exercise; gatekeeping; argument facilitation
Richard Kilborn (1992)
•Part of routine and entertaining reward
for work
•Launchpad of social and personal
interaction
•Fulfilling individual needs – a way of
choosing to be alone or of enduring enforced
loneliness
•Identification or involvement with
characters
•Escapist fantasy
•Focus of debate on topical issues
•Kind of critical game involving knowledge
of rules or conventions of the genre
Criticisms:
•We may not have choice about what
we watch
•Neglects any aspects of effects
theories
•Neglects socio-economic factors
Reception Theory:
Active
vs
Passive
Reception Theory
vs
Effects Theory
•Often as opposite to Effects theories
•Sees media consumption as active not
passive
•Suggests media texts are polysemic
•Research examines social, cultural,
economic, gender, sexuality as influence on the
reading of media texts
The Nationwide Audience:
•Different
social/economic groups watched same TV programme
•Interviews
reveal different readings of same text
•Dominant
(Hegemonic) reading: reader shares the encoded meanings of
the text
•Negotiated
reading:
reader shares some of the embedded ideologies but not all
•Oppositional
(counter-hegemonic) reading: where the reader does not share the
programme’s code and rejects the preferred reading
•Members
of the same subculture will tend to decode texts in similar ways.
Individual readings of texts will be framed by shared cultural formations and
practices.
The Preferred Reading:
•Those producing the media promote a particular interpretation of events- the preferred
reading.
reading.
•Those lacking direct experience of
the events covered in the media are likely to accept this preferred
reading.
reading.
•Those with direct experiences of
the events covered in the media are likely to reject this preferred reading.
•Repetition of the preferred reading
over a period of time leads to acceptance for the majority.
Modes of Address:
•How
a text is constructed to make us feel that it is specifically aimed at us.
•The
ways in which texts are built to appeal to particular audiences (Skins, children's
programmes, The Sun).
Cultivation Theory:
·Cultivation theory is when the viewer gets confused between reality and media.
·The more they see of something through media, the more they think it will happen in real life.
·Fear is one of the effects of the cultivation theory.
·An example of this is 'Crimewatch', which features reality, but presents situations that are very rare, which
could lead viewers to believe that the crimes will happen to them due to the frequent discussion of crime.
Mean World Syndrome Theory:
·This is very similar to the Cultivation Theory
·However, this theory focuses more on fear based around the passiveness of a particular audience
·This theory explains how television has long lasting effects which are gradual but still significant
·Theoretically, viewers who consume a lot of media believe the world to be a dangerous and fearful place
despite the fact that crime rates are actually falling.
Cultivation Theory:
·Cultivation theory is when the viewer gets confused between reality and media.
·The more they see of something through media, the more they think it will happen in real life.
·Fear is one of the effects of the cultivation theory.
·An example of this is 'Crimewatch', which features reality, but presents situations that are very rare, which
could lead viewers to believe that the crimes will happen to them due to the frequent discussion of crime.
Mean World Syndrome Theory:
·This is very similar to the Cultivation Theory
·However, this theory focuses more on fear based around the passiveness of a particular audience
·This theory explains how television has long lasting effects which are gradual but still significant
·Theoretically, viewers who consume a lot of media believe the world to be a dangerous and fearful place
despite the fact that crime rates are actually falling.
Cultural hegemony
•Devised by Antonio Gramsci
•Marxist
•A section of society has
authority over the rest through consent, not force
•Ruling class ideologies
seen as universal with benefits to all
•Ideas of the ruling class
seen as normal or taken for granted
•Common sense itself become
site of ideological struggle



No comments:
Post a Comment