Sunday, 22 September 2013

How could passive audience effects models be applied to the representation of youth in the media?

The passive audience theory is the idea that the media ‘injects’ ideas and views directly into the brains of the audience like a hypodermic needle, therefore, controlling the way that people think and behave. It is further divided into two models: The first, the ‘Hypodermic Needle Model’ where the intended message is directly received and wholly accepted by the receiver. The second, the Marxist ‘Cultural Effects Model’ sees the media as a powerful ideological influence that is mainly concerned with transmitting capitalist values and norms (perhaps that is why the media seems hell-bent on making us all fear each other, thus promoting the idea of individualism). The ‘Cultural Effects Model’ is essentially the same as the ‘Hypodermic Syringe Model’ except it is more gradual and not everyone comes to accept it.

In the film ‘Village of the Damned’, the collective identity of youth is presented as superior to their older counterparts. This is developed through the dialogue between the adults and the children; ‘We know all your secrets’, meaning that unlike the norm of adults being firmly in control of youths (or, at least, that was the view of youth represented in the media of the era), the youths have great power over the adults due to their (again, atypical) psychic abilities. In the wake of this film, many children began to believe that they may have psychic abilities and tried to utilise them, thus rendering this an example of the ‘Hypodermic Syringe Theory’ as they immediately believed and wanted to believe in something so fantastical to make them feel some sort of equality with adults as they were so used to being repressed. This power is further shown through the frequent use of ECUs of the youths’ glowing eyes. Gang culture is also presented in the film but not in the usual violent and aggressive manner, unlike our modern media.

In ‘The Inbetweeners’, we are presented with youths extremely typical of those represented in our media; confused, awkward, disrespectful and perpetually horny. On the other hand, unlike the representation of youth we are so used to, we are led to sympathise with the protagonist Will and he is represented as an innocent victim of an extremely difficult age and society’s expectations of him. The other three main characters are obsessed with sex and getting drunk, very typical youth interests and completely unlike those of the children in ‘Village of the Damned’. ‘The Inbetweeners’ is an example of the ‘Cultural Effects Model’ as the more we watch the series, the less youths want to be like the characters and the further adults sneer at youths and judge them. The stereotypes in the series are extremely consistent with the stereotypes that we are presented with every day on the news.


Another programme that presents youths in a very typical manner is Eastenders, e.g. Liam getting stabbed by a rough group of so-called ‘friends’ (knife crime and gang culture) and Lauren’s drinking problems (underage drinking and alcoholism). The programme is usually gritty and realistic but occasionally turns some youths’ problems into hyperbole, another thing we often see in the news, particularly when they assume that the minority represent the majority. With the support of the news stories that we see about youths, the programme is an example of both the ‘Cultural Effects Model’ and the ‘Hypodermic Syringe Model’;  adults immediately assume that all teenagers are troublemakers and ‘ne’er-do-wells’ or youths  immediately have a strong desire to prove the programme makers wrong, while other  youths eventually emulate the behaviour shown as they believe that ‘if this is already what they think we do, why not just do it?’.

No comments:

Post a Comment